The judiciary as society’s shield: a sociological case
Mohamed Shabeer Zafar says courts must curb executive abuse, citing bail rulings, a beaten MP video and fears for Mr. Mohamed’s life.
Dear Editor,
Sociology holds that legitimacy flows from fairness, not force. Tom Tyler’s procedural justice research shows citizens accept even unfavourable outcomes when processes are neutral, reasoned, and respectful.1 Max Weber argued authority endures only when the governed believe it rightful. Courts are where that belief is built or destroyed.
Judicial restraint of the executive offers three societal benefits.
First, it preserves the presumption of innocence, the moral minimum of a liberal order. The three men remanded on national-security data charges are untried at Sparendaam.
Law & Application. Magistrates must balance innocence against flight risk, public safety and public confidence. None of the men has a conviction, and Cybercrime Act charges aren’t violent crimes. Bail jurisprudence favours release on the lightest conditions (R v Antic, Canada, 2017) and makes release the default (R (O) v Harrow Crown Court [2006] UKHL 42). Bail depends on the person’s own circumstances (R v Mansfield Justices, ex p Sharkey [1985]), and “public confidence” demands individualised, reasoned analysis, not public mood (R v Hall, 2002; R v St-Cloud, 2015 (Canada). Chief Magistrate Latchman’s refusal at Georgetown to revoke Mr. Mohamed’s existing bail, because unproven allegations didn’t justify detention, reflects that discipline.
Second, it checks the weaponisation of state agencies. Foucault warned that policing and prosecution can become instruments of selective control. Independent scrutiny interrupts that tendency. The video of a surrendered Member of Parliament allegedly beaten by State servants, and the contrast between sentence reductions for a convicted domestic abuser and the denial of leniency to two presumed-innocent young constables, feed perceptions of unequal justice. Durkheim understood that such perceptions erode social solidarity and breed cynicism. One of the constables’ attorneys has said his client will stand alongside figures like Nelson Mandela for resisting oppression. A respected trade unionist has also condemned the State’s treatment of the LOTO and the two constables, and Paul Slowe, a retired public officer alleged corruption on an independent television broadcast on 3 November.
Third, it gives ordinary people a way to seek help through the courts. Mrs. Bonita Mohamed’s case, which names 3 respondents, shows a mother choosing the law over violence or protest.
In T&T on 26 June 2026, Justice Robin Mohammed ordered the State to pay over $2.5 million to Samantha Isaacs’s estate. He found that failures by the State, including the police and a magistrate, helped cause her death after her warnings were ignored.
That supports looking into Mr. Mohamed’s fears for his life. He says many shots were fired at him around 12 October, and he repeated this on the court steps on 2 November. Warnings like this should be looked into, not brushed aside. His coming call looks like a cry for help, and it must be treated as the top concern.
Conclusion: When courts grant bail with firm conditions, they signal that law binds rulers and ruled alike, converting grievance into institutional trust and stabilising democracy. The video of a surrendered MP beaten by State servants should trouble us. Like Richard III, a tyrant may soon cry, “A horse! A horse! My kingdom for a horse!” When a regime’s friends walk free and its critics are held, trust dies.
Yours faithfully,Mohamed Shabeer ZafarBarrister & solicitor
References
1 source- 1Tom Tylertyler.socialpsychology.org