Economics & Trade

Robots will work, billionaires will profit

Rajendra Bisessar says robots and AI will funnel more wealth to capitalists, leaving workers on a basic wage and the system choking on inequality.

10 November 20264 min / 998 words

Dear Editor,

Elon Musk stated that robots would be able to do most work by humans and do it better. When asked about the resulting unemployment he said maybe a basic wage would be necessary.

My first reaction was this guy wants the majority of people to live just above the level of being able to survive while the top 10% of owners of the means of production live the life of super luxury.

It is my opinion that Elon has no real understanding of the realities. Most discussions within the framework taught to us by the very elites that control the means of production and the means of disseminating information.

The other approach is trying to understand the nature of the system, how that system operates and what drives socioeconomic transition. We need to understand first that the present system was not always there but replaced a previous system that ceased to advance the world. The present capitalist system created some progress but has now become retrogressive and has ceased to do so.

So let us examine. We are told that competition is good and necessary. But the very competition leads to monopoly as one company innovates, reduces costs and puts its competitors out of business. Free enterprise capitalism transitions to monopoly capitalism and so monopoly prices which increase profits. Remember maximization of profits is the main drive and objective of capitalism. The capitalists want to get rich then move from millionaires to billionaires and now they want to be trillionaires.

So, we need to understand the shift of this wealth and the consequences of this shift. Technology has been the driving factor that drives socioeconomic change. As man develops tools and knowledge of agriculture and horticulture it transformed the way people live. And they moved away from being hunters and gatherers and nomadic to living in stable communities.

We need to never fail to understand that in the beginning there was only land and labour with no means of production and it is labour that created all values. Even as we see equipment and factories that are owned by individuals the production of these was by both skilled and unskilled labour. So labour is the basis of all production.

At some stage in history, the means of production ended up in the hands of a few and then the others were employed by the owners and a share of the product of their labour went to the owners who appropriated the surplus which was used for reinvestment, the employment of more labour and so an accumulation of wealth by the owners of the means of production.

An important fact to note is that as technology improved and the productivity of labour increased a greater share of the Increase went to the owners of the means of production. So, with low technology two blankets were produced. The workers would have one and the capitalist one. As productivity increased and by the time five blankets were produced the capitalists got three and the worker two.

Later we got automation and less and less workers were needed as they were replaced by computers the share of the capitalists increased. While the workers received more than before as a percentage of what they produced, they got less as a percentage of what is produced and the capitalist more.

Then came robots and so less and less workers. Now AI can replace even skilled workers and work that needs mental proficiency. So less and less is going to the workers and a greater share to the capitalists.

Statistics show that the capitalist receives an increasing share of the GDP. While the gap between the haves and the have not increases.

The problem is as the share of national income shifts to a small percentage of the population the amount of wealth in the hands of the people is reduced. So, while they have needs, they do not have the money to buy what is produced. The robots which play a great role in producing do not buy consumer goods, do not go to hotels, buy cars, etc.

The capitalists have a greater share of the money and they have the goods in the bonds. The population do not have the money to buy them. The capitalists have the money to buy them but cannot consume them. To get profits the goods have to be sold. So, you can appreciate how the structure of the system has resulted in a bottle neck.

So, as Elon said, the people would be given a basic wage but this basic wage would not be able to purchase the goods produced. The solution they found is war. I call it destructive consumption. We make bombs and military equipment and blow them up. So, they need an enemy. Russia was communist and so the enemy. Now, they are capitalist and still the enemy. So, we tell the people we need second generation then third generation equipment. We have fields of the previous generation. And then we have wars like the Ukraine war, Iraq, Afghanistan wars. we destroy the weapons and so we have to order more from the Military industrial complex. No wars they lay off thousands of workers and the economy collapses.

We can see how technological advances create and deepen the contradiction within the system. I have not discussed how money is power and how your votes do not matter as the politicians are controlled by the rich.

I am hoping that you may begin to understand how systems operate, how and why feudalism had to transition to capitalism and why capitalism needs to transition. The discussion should not be which system is better as the capitalist propaganda machine has effectively conditioned us. The issue is to understand the structure of economic systems and understand how they develop and transition. Our education system does not teach us this and more often than not we simply regurgitate the capitalist propaganda machine feeds us.

Sincerely,Rajendra Bisessar