Skip to content
Replying toJagdeo’s overtures to APNU may represent revealing moment in Guyana’s political evolutionLetter 2 of 2

Mohamed misuses the authoritarian test

Conversation

2 letters, Oct 19 to Nov 15
  1. replied 27 days later
    The Civic Observer
    Mohamed misuses the authoritarian test (this letter)
    Guyana Times, Nov 15

Dear Editor,

Hadiyyah Mohamed has traded St Andrews for Harvard. Her latest essay lays the PPP/C beside the four warning signs of authoritarianism in Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt’s ‘How Democracies Die’ and declares Guyana “a full-blown dictatorship”. The book is serious. Her use of it is not. The test was built to screen anyone who seeks power, not to sentence one side. She applied it to the Government alone, and the method is her dissertation all over again. Of the sixteen indicators she lists, six carry no example at all. They sit on the page like boxes she hoped the reader would tick for her.

  1. Denial of the legitimacy of political opponents

Mr Jagdeo’s “devil” remark of July 2025 was aimed at the AFC’s willingness to partner with a US-sanctioned man. It was rough language, but no rival was barred. Six parties contested the election, and Azruddin Mohamed was declared Leader of the Opposition in January 2026. Nor was he “baselessly” labelled a criminal. The US Treasury designated him in June 2024, and a federal grand jury indicted him on eleven counts.[1] He is presumed innocent. That is not the same as being baselessly accused.

  1. Toleration or encouragement of violence

She calls 12 October Prem Narine’s “clear” assassination attempt. Nothing about it is clear, which is why it is in court. Police say a shot came from the car; the defence says the gun was planted, and new footage raises fair questions that deserve answers. But Mr Narine has been cross-examined in open court by Mr Mohamed’s lawyers, and the press printed his concessions. Regimes that protect their gunmen do not do that.

The “petty, bailable” offence is an allegation that he paid a constable $800,000 for state surveillance footage. It carries five years on indictment, and he was already on bail for firearm and obstruction charges. “Bailable” means a court decides. A court did. The High Court has since warned that any oppressive conditions “will not be continued”, fast-tracked his challenge and refused the State’s bid to dismiss it[2], while the Chief Magistrate refused Washington’s bid to revoke his extradition bail[3]. Dictatorships do not lose in their own courts. And when protesters demanding his release forced down barricades and threw bottles at police on 2 November, her essay found nothing to condemn.

  1. Readiness to curtail civil liberties, including the media

Reporters should not have been kept out of the Sparendaam courtroom, and the EU did find pro-Government bias in the media. Those are fair points. But the same mission called the media “vibrant”, and the Press Association complaint she cites[4] names politicians “across the political spectrum”. Mr Mohamed has played State surveillance video at a press conference and broadcast live from a police station. The bank closures were compliance decisions over his US sanctions[5], and where banks erred, Guyanese judges awarded WIN members damages. On 11 November, as his supporters protested outside Parliament, his sister was sworn in and congratulated by the Prime Minister. Find me the dictatorship that does that.

  1. Rejection of democratic rules of the game

This is the author’s first test, and three of her four indicators under it are blank. The fourth rests on the EU’s “uneven playing field”, a real problem worth reforming. The same report found the polls peaceful, well-run and markedly more transparent. The man who rejected credible results was Mr Mohamed, who declared “I won the elections” and, by the reported account, offered no proof.

5 AND 6. Mutual toleration and institutional forbearance

Toleration runs both ways. It is not served by calling every adverse ruling persecution, or by attacking a state witness online after a magistrate has ordered the posts to stop. Forbearance binds the state, and the courts are holding it there. It binds private power too. Guards beaten with a bat on the family’s premises and tax officers turned back at its gate: that is power without forbearance.

  1. The Gatekeepers

The book’s real warning is about established parties that open the door to a figure they should keep out, believing they can use him. In July 2025, the AFC said it would join forces with “anyone”, WIN included. That is the abdication Levitsky and Ziblatt describe.

None of this is a conviction. Mr Mohamed is presumed innocent, and October 12 must be settled on the evidence. Guyana’s democracy has flaws worth fixing. But a dictatorship does not seat its critics’ families in Parliament, lose in its own courts or let its intelligence chief be cross-examined in public. Levitsky and Ziblatt wrote a warning. Ms Mohamed has turned it into an alibi.

Yours sincerely,
The Civic Observer

References

  1. Azruddin Mohamed, father indicted by US on 11 countswww.stabroeknews.com ↩
  2. High Court rejects US-sanctioned LOO’s interim bail bid, fast-tracks substantive challengeguyanatimesgy.com ↩
  3. Chief Magistrate again refuses bid to revoke Azruddin Mohamed’s bailkiskadeewatch.com ↩
  4. Statement by the Guyana Press Association on treatment of media workerspressassociation.gy ↩
  5. Central Bank says advised Azruddin Mohamed to withdraw ...www.stabroeknews.com ↩
Source