Skip to content

Maritime and ocean safety system is a total failure

Dear Editor,

The testimony of Captain John Flores before the Commission of Inquiry into the MV Barima sinking should be required reading for every Guyanese who has ever boarded a ferry — and for Mr. Juan Edghill, whom I now am convinced is highly unfit for the job he holds.

Captain Flores enlisted in the Guyana Defence Force in 1981 and served as Commanding Officer of the Guyana Defence Force Coast Guard for many years. He studied at the Royal Naval College in the United Kingdom and was certified as a Search and Rescue Planner in the United States in 1993. After retiring from the Coast Guard as the most senior ranked Amerindian naval officer in Guyana, he transitioned to MARAD as Director of Maritime Safety, from where he departed a few years ago to enjoy his full retirement. Despite his retirement, he remains a well-trained Guyanese with much still to offer this nation, and he should be appointed General Manager of the Transport and Harbours Department forthwith.

At the Commission of Inquiry into the MV Barima[1], Captain Flores admitted that an earlier identification of the vessel could have given rescuers an additional hour — an hour that, in his own words, would have saved “all of those lives who came out of the boat alive. Almost certain.” Let that sink in, Mr. Edghill. You did this nation wrong.

Captain Flores described the first two hours of the rescue as “chaotic.” That single word says much about the leadership of the current Coast Guard Commander Mr. David Shamshudeen — chaotic. Captain Flores conceded that communication between the Coast Guard, fishermen, aircraft and maritime personnel was poor; that different groups operated independently; that sightings and coordinates did not reach those actively searching at sea; and that the vessel could not be reached through the lighthouse because of “limitations” in its radio equipment. One of the first persons on the water was the Leader of the Opposition, Mr. Azruddin Mohamed[2], yet the Government was determined not to communicate with him, further placing dozens of lives at stake in a tragedy where this nation eventually lost many who could have been saved. This one is on you, Mr. Edghill. Thank you again Mr. Azruddin.

Most damning of all was Captain Flores’ testimony that safety inspectors inside MARAD told him they could not accurately determine whether vessels were operating within safe loading limits because stability documentation was absent. There was no comprehensive register of which vessels recovered which survivors and bodies. Even the number of life rafts retrieved could not be confirmed. The maritime and ocean safety system in Guyana is, by itself, a national disaster.

What is emerging is an evidential and confirmatory portrayal that the maritime and ocean safety system in Guyana is a total failure and will continue to place the lives of anyone who uses a marine vessel in clear and present danger — outside of the oil and gas sector.

Every passenger who boards a Transport and Harbours Department ferry is placing their life in the hands of a system that cannot verify seaworthiness, cannot guarantee a distress call will be heard, and cannot promise a coordinated rescue. The 73 dead and the dozens still missing from the MV Barima are the price of that failure.

I would therefore warn any traveller to desist from using a Transport and Harbours Department vessel if you can. It may be safer in Guyana to use a speedboat. It is time for passengers to boycott the use of these vessels. Even vehicle owners should board their vehicle, get off at the other side, and take a speedboat across, so that when another Transport and Harbours Department vessel sinks, the only loss will be your vehicle and not your life. The Transport and Harbours Department cannot and should not be trusted with your life. You enter those boats at great risk to your life.

I therefore make this public oath: I will never travel on a Transport and Harbours Department ferry until international safety standards are fully implemented across the entire fleet, including independent stability verification and enforced load limits; until a modern, interoperable communication system links vessels, lighthouses, the Coast Guard and rescue coordination with no “limitations”; until a transparent public register of safety certifications and inspection results is available to all passengers; until a fully funded, professionally staffed Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre is mandated to respond to all distress calls with maximum resources; and until those responsible for the MV Barima tragedy are held to account and a permanent independent oversight body ensures lessons are never forgotten.

Until then, I will not entrust my life to a system that has demonstrated, in the most tragic way possible, that it cannot guarantee the safety of its passengers. The dead deserve more than inquiries and admissions of chaos. They deserve a ferry service that treats every passenger as a life worth protecting.

Yours faithfully,
Surujdai Juglall

References

  1. MV Barima inquiry sets four days for survivors, relatives to testifykiskadeewatch.com ↩
  2. OPPOSITION LEADER AZRUDDIN MOHAMED EXPLAINING TO THE MEDIA HOW HE ENDED UP IN THE VICINITY OF THE…flexlinkmedia.com ↩
Source