Adding to Rohee — Dr. Jagan in India

16 November 20265 min / 1218 words

Dear Editor,

I echo the sentiments made by Clement Rohee, “India Revisited” (Oct 28) about modernization and poverty in India. Rohee first visited India in 1982, three years before my first of dozens and will undertake another next month for an indentureship conference and the Pravasi Bharatiya Divas in Kolkata. Rohee said his second trip was with Dr. Jagan in 1993. I will like to make some anecdotal comments regarding Jagan’s visits to Delhi, his first in 1953 and another in 1971. First some comments and observations as well as some facts about India.

India is a fascinating country, great for studying and to conduct research in so many subjects including on the life of our fore-bearers who left India and were indentured in Guyana and other territories. (I studied in India earning two doctorates and made multiple trips as a guest lecturer to conduct research as well as to participate in conferences organised by the Ministry of External Affairs and India Center for Cultural Relations). India has been very generous to Guyana, providing free technical assistance and hundreds of scholarships to Guyanese of all races, including to President Ali and Minister Zulfikar Ally.

India has made tremendous developmental progress since becoming an independent nation. Socialism held back development. The country started to open up in the 1990s, a decade after China did. Aside from China, no country has made such great developmental strides as India, rapid development. India has been the fastest growing emerging economy over the last decade and is the fifth largest economy on the verge of becoming the fourth. COVID and the Iran War has held back India’s rapid growth and development. Western nations have tried to stymie India’s economic and technological progress.

As Rohee stated, India has made great strides since his first trip in 1983. After my first trip in 1985, I made dozens of trips to India and observed the progress. As an illustration, when I first visited India in 1985 on all expenses paid visiting scholar programme, there were hardly any skyscrapers. Today, there are thousands. Sections of some cities look like New York or Shanghai or Hong Kong. In the 1980s and even in the 1990s, there were regular blackouts in hotels. Today, a blackout is a rarity, certainly not in a luxury hotel. In the 1980s, there were few five star and zero seven stars hotels. Today, there are hundreds. Service at hotels was not the greatest during the 1980s and 1990s. Today, they are among the best in the world, far ahead in the Western world. There is certainly value for money at any hotel in India.

As Rohee said, there is poverty and skewed income. But India has eliminated widespread poverty. In 1947 at independence, poverty was 80%. In 1985, it dropped to 44%. In 2014 when Modi ji became PM, it was 23%. Today it is less than 3%. Modi took some 230 millions out of poverty in ten years. Compare that with the high percentage of poverty in Guyana!

Take another comparison, the size of the Indian economy as a percentage of global economy when Britain colonized India in the 1800s was 24%. When Britain left in 1947, it dropped to 3%. Today, it has climbed to 10%. Like Rohee did in his last trip in October, I too visited all the named cities and more, and also countless villages, from East to West, North to South. I visited the villages and Districts of all eight of my great grandparents and also found some ancestral relatives. All of them have made some progress since my ancestors lest there in the 1880s and 1890s.

On anecdotes related to Jagan, when I visited India as a doctoral student in 1985, in socializing encounters at lecture halls and in my own lectures, I met several scholars, ex bureaucrats, and government officials who fondly recalled meeting Jagan when he visited with Burnham in 1953 and again in 1971 during the war with Pakistan. He revisited in 1993 as President.

Each of Dr. Jagan’s visit took place under vastly different political circumstances in India and under different leadership. Yet the reception he received from the Indian public, the media, and politicians consistently reflected a deep emotional and ideological bond with a man widely regarded as a fearless champion of the oppressed and a proud son of the diaspora. Indian academics and bureaucrats (retirees) recalled the enduring affection, respect, and solidarity of the Indian public for the socialist Cheddi although some stated they warned him about Burnham and the dangers of his ideology in USA backyard. Nevertheless, they admired his anti-colonial resistance and his struggle against the dictatorship post-independence. Some followed our struggle for restoration of democracy.

Jagan was front page news in India in 1953. Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru welcomed Jagan and Burnham warmly, lending moral weight to their plight. Most notably, in an extraordinary gesture of solidarity, Jagan and Burnham were invited to address an informal joint gathering of members of both Houses of the Indian Parliament. The Indian press covered his every move, portraying him as a David standing up to the Goliath of British imperialism. Across lecture halls, public forums, and civic gatherings, ordinary Indians, students, and intellectuals rallied around Jagan, viewing British Guiana’s struggle for self-determination as an extension of India’s own freedom movement.

In 1971, Jagan visited Bengali refugee camps and commiserated with the victims. They admired him as an anti-colonial and anti-dictatorial hero, underscoring the enduring loyalty he commanded among the Indian public, intelligentsia, and progressive movements. They still saw him as a victim of imperial overreach. The intellectual reception for Jagan remained deeply personal and enthusiastic. Academics, journalists, and veteran parliamentarians who remembered his fiery 1953 speeches welcomed him back as an old comrade. His outspoken solidarity with India during the 1971 humanitarian and geopolitical crisis further endeared him to the Indian public, cementing his reputation as a steadfast friend who stood with India in its hour of need.

Pandit Ramlall recounted meeting Dr. Jagan at a public engagement in the ballroom of a hotel in Delhi in 1993 when he was accompanied by Rohee who was Foreign Minister. He was given an electric reception, treated as a hero. Those who I met in my trip after Jagan’s recounted his exhilarating speeches on development. He was a poor man advocate.

It was

a triumphant homecoming. Returning to India at the age of 75 as a sitting Head of State, he was accorded full ceremonial honors, but it was the warmth of the public response that truly defined the trip. For the Indian public, Jagan’s presence in 1993 represented the ultimate vindication of democratic perseverance. Newspapers and television broadcasts celebrated the remarkable arc of his life: the grandson of indentured laborers who had endured colonial ousters and decades of political exile to become the President of his nation. Wherever he went — from official engagements with President Shankar Dayal Sharma and Prime Minister P. V. Narasimha Rao to public receptions and visits to ancestral regions — crowds greeted him with a mixture of reverence and familial pride. To ordinary Indians, Jagan was no longer just a distant political ally; he was an elder statesman of the global Indian diaspora whose integrity and resilience had outlasted the Cold War itself.

Yours truly,Vishnu Bisram