Legal competence is not dictatorship
Jaideo Jairam says Nandlall’s courtroom wins reflect opposition legal blunders, not “dictatorship” or state tyranny.
To Editor,
The current political narrative portraying Attorney General Mohabir Anil Nandlall, SC, as an instrument of “dictatorship” because of his unbroken string of courtroom victories against government opponents, ignores nearly a decade of Guyanese legal history.
Long before the People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) returned to office, Mr. Nandlall was already dismantling the flimsy constitutional arguments of the APNU+AFC coalition—not from a seat of State power, but from the opposition benches. Today’s opposition figures are simply repeating the same pattern of legal miscalculation and crying authoritarianism whenever independent judges enforce the law.
In any constitutional democracy, keeping a government legally secure requires rigorous adherence to statutory procedure and constitutional text. Mr. Nandlall’s mastery of this discipline was firmly established prior to 2020.
Following the December 21, 2018 passage of the historic No-Confidence Motion by a 33-to-32 vote,1 the APNU+AFC administration invented an absurd mathematical formula claiming an “absolute majority” required 34 votes. Mr. Nandlall exposed that fallacy before the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), securing landmark rulings that validated the motion and struck down the unilateral appointment of retired Justice James Patterson as GECOM Chairman.2
That pattern of opposition defeat continued during the five-month 2020 electoral impasse, where Mr. Nandlall successfully defeated dozens of meritless filings aimed at halting the national recount—including the notorious Eslyn David litigation that sought to manufacture “valid votes” hurdle out of thin air.3 Even after leaving office, APNU+AFC filed two election petitions—including Election Petition No. 88—both of which collapsed in the High Court and Court of Appeal due to fatal procedural errors and improper service.4 Now as Attorney General, Mr. Nandlall brings that exact same precision to protecting the State, shielding the PPP/C administration from valid claims of executive overreach.
More recently, his defense of statutory procedure was on full display in the extradition proceedings involving Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed. When defence attorneys filed premature High Court challenges against the Fugitive Offenders Act and sought interim bail through improper interlocutory motions,5 Mr. Nandlall systematically dismantled those filings on settled jurisprudential grounds. He demonstrated that issuing an authority to proceed is an administrative trigger rather than a judicial act, and that due process objections belong inside committal hearings.
Why, then, do government detractors brandish every courtroom loss from 2018 to 2026 as proof of “dictatorship”? Because it is far easier to attack the integrity of the courts than to admit poor legal strategy. Whether it was APNU+AFC’s “34-vote” fantasy or current opposition litigants padding affidavits with inadmissible hearsay and political speeches, losing cases stem from defective lawyering, not state tyranny. Worse still, when legal arguments fail inside the courtroom, some elements resort to street intimidation outside the Georgetown Magistrates’ Courts.
Democracy is not measured by an equal distribution of courtroom wins. It is measured by resolving disputes peacefully through established legal channels. Here is a word of constructive advice for those opposing the government: stop treating the courts as a stage for political theatre, retain counsel who respect strict procedural rules, and bring sound constitutional arguments rather than grievances. From holding APNU+AFC accountable in opposition to keeping the PPP/C legally safe in government, Mr. Nandlall has consistently upheld constitutional order.
Yours truly,Jaideo Jairam
References
5 sources- 1VIDEO: Gov't falls after APNU+AFC MP Charrandas Persaud votes yes to no confidence motion - Stabroek Newsstabroeknews.com
- 2CCJ rulings on No-Confidence Motion, GECOM Chairman end “season of stupidity” – Ramson | Guyana Standardguyanastandard.com
- 3Appeal Court rules “more votes cast” means “more valid votes cast” – Department of Public Information, Guyanadpi.gov.gy
- 4Court of Appeal Dismisses APNU+AFC's Election Petition ...ncnguyana.com
- 5High Court rejects US-sanctioned LOO’s interim bail bid, fast-tracks substantive challengenewsource.gy