Political Governance

No one is above the law

Tony mark Ramjewan says Azruddin Mohamed’s supporters cannot demand justice while excusing disorder outside the court.

16 November 20266 min / 1379 words

Dear Editor,

Guyana cannot claim to defend democracy while allowing political loyalty to take precedence over justice, accountability and the rule of law.

There is a question every Guyanese should be willing to answer, regardless of political affiliation: Do we genuinely believe in the rule of law, or do we only defend it when it protects the politicians we support?

What unfolded outside the Georgetown Magistrates’ Court as Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed appeared in connection with his ongoing legal proceedings deserves serious reflection. Supporters gathered to express their dissatisfaction, but what should have remained an exercise of peaceful democratic expression reportedly escalated into disorder. Police barricades were pushed down, tensions intensified, and officers responded with tear gas and pellets.

I understand political loyalty. I understand frustration. I also understand that citizens have every right to question the fairness of legal proceedings, particularly when those proceedings involve a prominent opposition figure.

Let me be clear: I support Azruddin Mohamed politically. But supporting him does not mean defending every action taken in his name, nor does it mean abandoning my belief in the rule of law.

There is a fundamental difference between supporting a political leader and blindly defending everything associated with that individual. We must be capable of recognising that difference if Guyana is to develop a more mature political culture.

Mohamed faces serious allegations, including a charge under Guyana’s Cybercrime Act relating to the alleged unauthorised obtaining and disclosure of confidential police surveillance footage. He and a police officer are accused in connection with the alleged transfer of that footage for payment. Mohamed has also been denied bail and remains in custody while challenging that decision before the High Court.

These are allegations, not established guilt. That distinction matters.

Every accused person is entitled to the presumption of innocence, legal representation, a fair hearing and the full protection of the law. Mohamed is no exception. His political position, wealth, popularity or relationship with his supporters must neither strengthen nor diminish those rights.

If there are legitimate concerns about how his case is being handled, they should be pursued through the courts and the appropriate constitutional channels. The judiciary must be allowed to function independently, without intimidation, political interference or pressure from the streets.

But the same principle must apply to those protesting.

You cannot demand respect for the justice system while disregarding the authority of the institutions responsible for administering justice.

A courthouse is not a political battleground. Police barricades are not obstacles to be destroyed simply because a crowd disagrees with a judicial decision. Frustration does not give anyone permission to intimidate officers, damage property or undermine public order.

Peaceful protest is a democratic right. It is an essential part of a functioning democracy. Citizens must be free to challenge decisions, question authority and express dissatisfaction without fear.

But peaceful protest and public disorder are not interchangeable.

A movement claiming to stand for justice must be careful not to undermine the very principles it says it is defending.

And this brings me to a question that I believe deserves far more attention.

What if the person facing these allegations were not Azruddin Mohamed, but President Dr. Mohamed Irfaan Ali?

Imagine that the President himself were facing comparable criminal allegations and had to appear before the courts.

Would the same supporters gather outside the courthouse demanding his immediate release? Would they challenge police barricades, confront officers and question the authority of the judiciary?

Would they insist that he be presumed innocent until proven guilty, or would they immediately demand accountability?

And if a court made a decision that went against him, would they defend the independence of that same judiciary?

Would the outrage be the same? Would the standards remain consistent?

That is the uncomfortable question.

It is easy to demand accountability when allegations involve someone we dislike. It is much harder when the person under scrutiny is someone we admire, support or believe represents our political interests.

But principles cannot be switched on and off depending on whose name appears in a court document.

If President Ali were accused of a criminal offence, he too would be entitled to due process, but he would also be subject to the law. The same applies to his ministers, government officials, opposition parliamentarians, businesspeople and ordinary citizens.

The President does not own the law. The Opposition does not own the law. And political supporters do not have the authority to decide who must answer to the courts and who deserves an exemption.

That is precisely why the rule of law exists. It protects ordinary citizens from the abuse of power while ensuring that those who hold wealth, influence and political office are not placed beyond accountability.

However, accountability must work in both directions.

The police have a responsibility to maintain public order, protect public safety and enforce the law. Officers should not be expected to stand helplessly while barricades are forced down or confrontations escalate.

Their safety matters, just as the safety of demonstrators and members of the public matters.

But that responsibility does not give law enforcement unlimited authority. Any use of force must be lawful, necessary and proportionate. The deployment of tear gas and pellets deserves scrutiny where legitimate questions arise about the circumstances in which they were used.

Respecting the police does not mean excusing misconduct. Equally, questioning police conduct does not mean excusing disorder.

We cannot demand accountability from demonstrators while refusing to demand accountability from authorities.

That is the standard a functioning democracy must uphold.

Guyana must also move beyond the dangerous assumption that every criticism of the government is an attack on the country, or that every investigation involving an opposition figure is automatically politically motivated.

Both positions undermine public confidence.

A government must accept scrutiny. An opposition must accept accountability. Neither political loyalty nor political office should determine how justice is administered.

I can support Azruddin Mohamed politically and still disagree with the conduct of demonstrators.

I can recognise the government’s responsibility to maintain public order while insisting that Mohamed receives every protection guaranteed under the law. I can question the actions of the police without defending those who disregard lawful authority.

There is no contradiction in those positions. It is called independent thinking.

And perhaps that is what Guyana needs most: citizens who are prepared to think beyond party colours, political personalities and partisan loyalties.

If you support Mohamed, demand a fair hearing, transparency and judicial independence. But do not confuse supporting his rights with defending disorder.

If you support President Ali, demand that his government respect the independence of the judiciary and answer legitimate questions. Do not dismiss every critic as an enemy.

The same standards must apply to everyone.

I would rather see supporters outside a courthouse peacefully demanding transparency, due process and accountability than see barricades destroyed and confrontations with police officers. I would rather see political leaders encouraging restraint than allowing frustration to deepen divisions.

Politicians come and go. Governments change. Opposition leaders rise and fall. But the institutions that protect the rights of every Guyanese must remain stronger than the individuals who temporarily occupy positions of power.

Ultimately, democracy is not measured by how fiercely we defend the politicians we support. It is measured by whether we are prepared to defend the principles that protect everyone, including those with whom we disagree.

Today, it is Azruddin Mohamed. Tomorrow, it could be Irfaan Ali. It could be a government minister, an opposition parliamentarian, a police officer, a businessperson or an ordinary citizen without political connections.

The standard must never change.

Investigate where there is evidence. Charge where the law permits. Allow the courts to determine guilt or innocence. Protect peaceful protest. Hold law enforcement accountable. And never allow political pressure to replace due process.

Guyana belongs to all its citizens, not to one political party, one administration or one political personality.

No one is above the law. Not an ordinary citizen. Not an Opposition Leader. Not a government minister. And certainly not the President of the Republic of Guyana.

If we cannot agree on that basic principle, perhaps we need to ask ourselves a much bigger question: Are we truly defending democracy, or are we simply defending the political side we happen to support?

Yours sincerely,Tony mark Ramjewan