Suppression of opposing views helped to consolidate dictatorial power

16 November 20262 min / 464 words

Dear Editor,

Is there a new dispensation in Guyana? Recent utterances by His Excellency, Dr. President indicate that citizens of Guyana and, by extension, anyone who provides unfavourable comments of him or his government will have their social media posts removed.

Editor, I read that the government appointed a learned, Canadian-based attorney to be its agent to exercise speech control (https://rb.gy/fwrteb). While the learned attorney demonstrates his knowledge of the law, I do not know if he studied history. Neither am I a student in the law nor a student in history. However, I do know that I am a student of my own agency. As I reflect on speech control, my cursory reading of history takes me to Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union, and South Africa.

In a nutshell, those governments systematically eliminated political opposition and independent journalism, among other things. Under those governments, criticizing the government became illegal. Political opponents, journalists, and intellectuals faced death, imprisonment and persecution. Suppression of opposing views helped to consolidate dictatorial power, spread state-controlled ideology, and enabled the destruction of societies. Current events, not only home but also abroad, suggest history repeating itself. I will leave it for the future to feel the impact.

The popular Burt Bacharach song,

Walk on By

, written for a different context, seems quite fitting. While there may be debates about Dionne Warrick or Isaac Hayes singing the better version, I wonder if the lyrics provide a lens from which to view the intention to stoke fear. In that song, the writer alludes to broken love, public embarrassment and fragile dignity. In this new dispensation, I wonder if the allusion fits freedom. Should I cry each time there is the chance to meet freedom? Should I walk on by? Do I grieve in private when I see freedom? Freedom, should I get over losing you, even if I seem, broken and blue? Perhaps, my foolish pride, given all that I have left? Freedom, should I hide the tears and sadness you gave me, when you said goodbye?

My dear Editor, whether I choose to critique, criticize, or challenge, I reserve the right to do so. We live in a country with a Constitution. That living document protects, proclaims and preserves certain rights. Editor, when and how do we compliment to affirm what was done? When and how do we critique to correct what ought to have been done? And when and how do we challenge to inspire what has yet to be done? Maybe, just maybe, our learned attorney friend will provide guidance. Under the impending dispensation, it is possible you may never hear from me again. If you do, perhaps it will all be complementary of the government. But, then again, I will be my own agent.

Sincerely,Lester Archer