Political Governance

Double standard that has hollowed out our politics

Arthur William says the Mohamed family smeared President Ali’s mother, then cried foul when their own mother was mentioned.

17 November 20264 min / 882 words

Dear Editor,

“KEEP MY MOTHER’S NAME OUT OF YOUR MOUTH!” So wrote Hadiyyah Mohamed, newly sworn Member of Parliament, to an Attorney General she addressed as “Pinocchio,” “Lielall” and “Gabadu,” before inviting him to revisit what “your own Geeta teaches about karma.” On the principle, I agree with her entirely. Mothers have no place in this fight. The difficulty is that her family discovered the principle fifteen months after abandoning it.

Consider the record. On 12 August 2025, a leaked interview carried a businessman’s claim that the President’s mother, a retired educator, had collected kickbacks on government contracts. That same day, the businessman, Azeem Baksh, withdrew it and apologised to Mrs Bibi Ali. According to her statement of claim, Hana Mohamed nonetheless posted that “the truth is finally out showing how the PPP is rotten to its core,” and left it up before tens of thousands of followers. A woman who never stood for office became a “gangster granny.” Mrs Ali has since sued Hana Mohamed in the High Court for more than G$600 million, and Meta and a diaspora commentator in Ontario for CA$15 million.

Now set that beside last Thursday. The Attorney General’s account is that after a High Court hearing, Bonita Mohamed insulted two female State attorneys and, when one replied that they were “simply doing our jobs,” spat at her. The family denies it, and the facts will be settled where facts are settled. But note the difference in kind. The Attorney General described conduct alleged in the precincts of a court, by a party to the proceedings. Nobody invented a bribery scheme for Mrs Mohamed. Nobody called her a gangster. That is the difference between a report and a smear. And where, as the President asked, are the women activists now?

So when it is their mother, it is an outrage. When it was the President’s mother, it was “the truth.” None of this is hindsight. It was flagged in August 2025, in the heat of the campaign: a party barely months old had dragged political discourse to depths that not even APNU or the AFC, for all their faults, had descended to. A WIN operative physically attacked a woman on nomination day. The President’s mother, an elderly woman owed dignity, was subjected to vile and distasteful assaults. WIN’s trolls turned on the wives and families of those who dared to disagree. For all the bitterness of PPP and PNC politics over six decades, leaders fought hard, at times personally, but families were not fair game. This Opposition broke that convention, and the self-appointed custodians of decency who lectured the PPP/C about “nasty politics” did not lift a pen.

Which brings me to the latest complaint: that the President has engaged Canadian attorney Selwyn Pieters to pursue those who spread lies about him, his mother and his officials. “So you want me to sit back and allow people to assassinate the character of myself and senior officials,” he asked on Friday. The answer must be no. Where defamation is published from New York, read in Ontario and hosted in California, the remedy lies where the harm is suffered, and Mrs Ali is a Canadian citizen. The Mohameds applauded the courts when the High Court quashed some G$800 million in tax assessments against Hana and Bibi Mohamed. No one gets to celebrate the courts as plaintiff and call them intimidation as defendant.

This is the measure of how low the discourse has sunk. Fourteen months after the election, there is no costed programme. The leader’s economics amount to an uncosted pay rise of “at least” 100 per cent against a G$252 billion wage bill, and a dollar he said had slid to G$240 when the Bank of Guyana was quoting about G$210. The scholarship is a dissertation of 232 questionnaires that omitted the family’s own US Treasury file, then an essay declaring Guyana “a full blown dictatorship” from a woman sworn into Parliament that same week. The vocabulary is Pinocchio, Lielall and Gabadu. Policy has simply left the room.

The mechanism is not hard to trace. A family facing sanctions, an eleven-count indictment and extradition needs every legal step read as persecution, and villains are cheaper to manufacture than policies. Yet each attempt to fight the case outside the courtroom produces a new one inside it: firearm and obstruction charges after a night outside a witness’s home, a cybercrime charge over State footage allegedly bought from a constable for $800,000, a magistrate smeared online, and now two State attorneys. Each new charge is then held up as fresh proof of persecution. The defence manufactures its own evidence. Mr Mohamed is presumed innocent, but that presumption does not oblige the public to ignore the pattern.

Guyanese politics has never been gentle, but it has always had a floor. An Opposition exists to raise the standard of scrutiny: test the budget, cost the alternative, hold the Executive to account on the merits. This one has lowered the national conversation to the level of a household grievance, materially and egregiously diminishing the intellectual standard of our politics. An Opposition that can neither offer a policy nor keep the mothers out of it has nothing left but noise. Guyanese were promised an alternative. They got a family feud.

Yours faithfully,Arthur William