Filed under Political Governance

Former presidents bill is a blank cheque

Surujdai Juglall says the former presidents bill is a blank cheque meant to funnel uncapped perks to Irfaan Ali after 2030.

Published in Kiskadee Watch⁠

22 November 20265 min / 1,144 words

Dear Editor,

I have listened to the contribution of Minister Priya Manickchand to the debate on the Former Presidents (Benefits and Other Facilities) Bill 2026, and I reject her position. Her speech does not explain the Bill; it obscures it. I say so using her own words, not the caricature that this is simply about giving Mr. David Granger a dignified retirement. The more she spoke, the more it confirmed that this bill is a scheme of cunning tactics to stealthily unleash an unlimited cash injection into the life of Mr.. Irfaan Ali, after 2030. Let us be clear, this is the final term of President Irfaan Ali, his term is on a clock now. I will therefore make these five points to make my case:

First, the Bill is not the modest measure she describes. She invites the House to see clause two as a few small kindnesses — water, electricity, a telephone, “an attendant and a gardener.” But the same clause provides for “services of clerical and technical staff, if requested” and for personal household staff. “If requested” is not a limit; it is an open door. There is no cap, no ceiling, no audit, and no published schedule of what a former president may claim. The Minister asked, with feeling, “How much water you think President Granger need to bathe and water his plants with?” Well, I want to ask, how much water will we use on the Mega Farm on the Linden Highway, in addition to the Mansion at Leonora and the several executive properties in Queenstown, Georgetown? The honest answer is that the Bill does not say — and that is why it should be objected to in the current form because come 2031, a former president can be charging this country $100 million for water a year for the multiple properties and farms that he owns. Juxtapose that against the average pensioner who will not even be getting $6 million a year in 2031. A benefit without a limit is not dignity; its aristocratic highway robbery; is a blank cheque drawn on the sweat of the workers of Guyana.

Second, she cannot have the argument both ways. She insists the issue “is not about former President David Granger” but about the office, a national institution to be protected regardless of who holds it. Yet the same speech argues that the 2020 Act can only ever apply to Mr. Granger, that it was passed by people who “didn’t like the man,” and that rejecting the Bill means making him walk about “tin cup in hand, begging.” Firstly, it was Mr. Granger that signed the bill in 2020 into law. Secondly, her imagery of “tin cup” is not borne out with any truth, and the public can attest to this mendacity. The facts will prove that Mr. Granger is not a man in poverty, and no one has produced evidence that he is reduced to begging. Actually, Mr. Granger has donated a whole property in Georgetown to the Burnham Foundation. That is not the action of a man with “tin cup in hand, begging.” The effect of the three cards trick that Ms. Manickchand seemingly wanted to pull, was to fix our attention on Mr. Granger while the bill is written to truly apply to whoever holds the office after 2030. That is not principle; it is misdirection, it is subterfuge.

Third, the security argument is inflammatory and irrelevant. To justify uncapped provisions, she points to six persons charged for attacking public properties and asks whether we should cap the former president’s guard. That is not an argument about a benefits schedule. If there is a genuine security situation in Guyana, then the GDF and Police is most capable of doing a security assessment and whatever security measures needs to be taken, there is more than enough billions in the Police and Army budget to meet the assessed needs. It is most wicked to use a criminal charge as a device to silence scrutiny of an unjustified executive perk and to force unlimited benefits down the throats of the taxpayers. It is chalk and cheese, and we see what you are doing Ms. Manickchand.

Fourth, her comparison of herself to the Opposition is beside the point. She is entitled to defend her record, but the 44 schools, she claims were built with public money under the leadership of President Jagdeo, President Ramotar and President Ali. It is most disrespectful for her to try to steal the thunder of these Presidents. What is even more disrespectful is how she continues to sideline the current Minister of Education Ms. Sonia Parag who in my books is a better fit and more suitable for the Education Portfolio than Ms. Manickchand. Building schools is not education and those schools are not a personal gift from Ms. Manickchand to Guyana. Stop this nonsense immediately.

What we should have heard from Ms. Manickchand is what, precisely, is the taxpayer obliged to provide to a former president after 2030, for how long, at what cost, and under what oversight? The Minister spent far more time on the Opposition’s 200 taxes than on the text of the Bill she was commending. But by now, we all know the tactics, distraction as a means to deception. Typical Priya Manickchand; crocodile tears and empty publicity stunts is all that they know.

Fifth, the Bill should be sent back for a costed, published schedule. If the Government believes a former president should have water, lights, a gardener, clerical support and medical attendance, let it publish the annual cost now for Mr. David Granger, set a reasonable ceiling for his main home, apply a clear inflation adjusted indexation rule of no less than 10% increase every year, require annual disclosure, and let the Public Accounts Committee review it. But the taxpayers cannot be expected to be paying for water and electricity for the Mega Farm and all the post executive properties? There must be some codification when public funds are being used with clear definition. She cited the names of foreign statutes but not their provisions. Again, in true Priya’s fashion, subterfuge and deception. She offers a comparison that lacks specifics, but it is all in the smoke screen she seeks to project.

I do not doubt that the “Office of the former President” should be treated with dignity. But dignity is not purchased by writing an uncapped clause and asking the taxpayers to pay for it. That is insanity at its worst. The benefits owed to every former president should rest on clear laws, published costs and public accountability. The Government should withdraw this oppressive Bill and return with a codified one, so that the Guyanese people can know exactly what it will cost them to maintain the Office of the Former President of Guyana after 2030.

Yours faithfully,Surujdai Juglall