Freedom of speech is not a licence to libel
Arthur William says Guyana's Constitution protects criticism, but not Facebook libel against the President or his family.
Dear Editor,
There is a big debate going on about freedom of speech in Guyana. The President has come under heavy criticism for retaining an attorney to report Facebook users who make scandalous remarks about him and his Government. One case in particular involved libellous remarks about his mother. Some people are calling this an attack on free speech. I disagree, and I think the Constitution is very clear on this.
Let us start with what the Constitution actually says. Article 146(1) provides that no person shall be hindered in the enjoyment of his or her freedom of expression, “that is to say, freedom to hold opinions without interference, freedom to receive ideas, and information without interference, freedom to communicate ideas and information without interference.” That is a strong protection, and it should be. Every Guyanese has the right to criticise the Government, to disagree with its policies, and to say so publicly.
But the same article does not stop there. Article 146(2)(b) says that nothing done under the authority of any law shall be held to contravene this right to the extent that the law makes provision “that is reasonably required for the purpose of protecting the reputations, rights, and freedoms of other persons.” As such, the Constitution itself recognises that a person’s reputation is worth protecting and that freedom of expression has limits where it damages someone else’s good name.
Article 40(2) goes further. It says our fundamental rights and freedoms are subject to limitations “designed to ensure that the enjoyment of the said rights and freedoms by any individual does not prejudice the rights and freedoms of others or the public interest.” In other words, my right to speak does not override your right not to be defamed. And Article 146(3) states plainly that freedom of expression “does not relate to hate speeches or other expressions, in whatever form, capable of exciting hostility or ill-will against any person or class of persons.”
With the foregoing in mind, freedom of speech does not mean you have the freedom to scandalise and libel people’s character. When someone goes on Facebook and makes scandalous remarks about any individual, that is not free speech. That is a prostitution of freedom of speech. It is using the pretext of a constitutional right to do something the Constitution itself does not protect.
Now, what does the Constitution protect? It protects your right to speak on national development. It protects your opinion on Government policies, on the economy, on social issues, on how public money is spent, and on a wide range of other matters. Article 13 says the principal objective of our political system is “to establish an inclusionary democracy by providing increasing opportunities for the participation of citizens.” Criticism, debate and dissent are part of that. Nobody should be reported for saying a policy is bad or that a minister is not performing.
But there is a difference between criticising a policy and attacking a person’s character without evidence. If any citizen has evidence of wrongdoing, whether it is corruption, abuse of office or anything else, then there is a proper forum for that, and it is the court of law. Article 144(8) provides that any court established for “the determination of the existence or extent of any civil right or obligation” shall be “independent and impartial”, and that the case “shall be given a fair hearing within a reasonable time”. Article 149D(1) also guarantees that the State “shall not deny to any person equality before the law or equal protection and benefit of the law.”
Thus, the route is there. Take the evidence, file it as a civil matter, and let the court decide. That is how it works in a democracy governed by the rule of law. You do not get to be judge and jury on Facebook, damaging someone’s name with allegations you cannot prove, and then hide behind freedom of speech when you are called to account.
The President, like any other citizen, has the right to protect his reputation and his family’s reputation. Retaining an attorney to pursue libel is not an attack on free speech. He is using the same legal system that is open to every Guyanese. If the President is subject to the law, then those who libel him must be subject to the law too. That is what equality before the law means.
I think we need a more mature conversation about this. Freedom of speech is one of the most important rights we have, and it must be defended. But defending it also means not allowing it to be abused, because when people use it as cover for scandal and libel, they weaken the right for everyone else.
Yours faithfully,Arthur William